• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Analog IC Tips

Analog IC Design, Products, Tools Layout

  • Products
    • Amplifiers
    • Clocks & Timing
    • Data Converters
    • EMI/RFI
    • Interface & Isolation
    • MEMS & Sensors
  • Applications
    • Audio
    • Automotive/Transportation
    • Industrial
    • IoT
    • Medical
    • Telecommunications
    • Wireless
  • Learn
    • eBooks / Tech Tips
    • FAQs
    • EE Learning Center
    • EE Training Days
    • Tech Toolboxes
    • Webinars & Digital Events
  • Resources
    • Design Guide Library
    • Digital Issues
    • Engineering Diversity & Inclusion
    • LEAP Awards
    • Podcasts
    • White Papers
    • DesignFast
  • Video
    • EE Videos
    • Teardown Videos
  • EE Forums
    • EDABoard.com
    • Electro-Tech-Online.com
  • Engineering Training Days
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe

Vacuum tubes we still (have to) use: The photomultiplier tube, Part 2

November 18, 2019 By Bill Schweber

We live in a world of solid-state active devices that have made most vacuum tubes obsolete, but a few types remain as they are still indispensable.

Part 1 of this article explained the basics of the photomultiplier tube. This part looks into other PMT characteristics.

Q: Are there solid-state functional equivalents to the PMT?

A: Of course there are, and they work quite well in many applications. These alternatives include the silicon photomultiplier (SiPM), the avalanche photodiode (APD, and the single-photon avalanche photodiode (SPAD). However, each of these has issues, primarily related to internal (intrinsic) noise and sensitivity, that makes each less suitable for some applications. The PMT has the highest internal gain with the lowest internal noise – analogous to SNR – of the available options.

Q: What is the gain of a PMT?

A: It varies, but gain is largely a function of the number of dynodes (Figure 1) and is on the order of 105 to 106 and higher. In contrast, the gain of the basic APD is fairly low, the order of 102. While the apparent gain can be further increased by following it with a conventional low-noise electronic amplifier, the intrinsic noise will be “gained up “as well, and so SNR will not improve. It will actually degrade due to the amplifier’s own added noise.

 

Fig 1:The gain a of PMT is largely related to the number of dynodes, among other factors. (Image: Florida State University)

Q: Is noise the figure of merit for a PMT (or other photodetector)?

A: Noise is one, of course, as is gain, But the other figure of merit is “dark current,” which is the amount of current produced when there are no incident photons. Dark current establishes a noise floor for the device, and the lower the dark current is, the better. A high-end PMT has the lowest dark current of any photodetectors, with its dark current is due to thermal emissions of electrons from the photocathode, leakage current between dynodes, and even stray high-energy radiation

Always keep in many that in many high-end designs from DC to RF (GHz and higher), internal noise is one of the limiting factors in the achievable performance. As in most applications with low signal levels, the SNR of the first stage limits performance, and it’s critical to have a high-gain, low-noise first stage.

Q: Why not just take the small current developed at the cathode, and amplify it using an electronic amplifier?

A: Again, it’s a matter of noise; the photon-derived current is so small that it would be “swamped” by the noise of any electronic amplifier and thus be lost. In contrast, the PMT is a relatively low-noise, low-dark current device.

Q: What is the efficiency of the PMT?

A: Quantum efficiency is the percentage of impinging photons that are converted to electrons at the cathode; a typical value is about 30%. The cathode is key, of course, and its design and thickness involve tradeoffs. If it is too thick, more photons will be absorbed, but fewer electrons will be emitted from the back surface; however, if it is too thin, too many photons will pass through without being absorbed.

Q: Does the PMT require more circuitry than the solid-state alternatives?

A: The difference is modest, but you do need a higher-voltage supply for the dynodes and anode (about 1000 V).

Q: Who are the vendors of PMTs? What are the attributes of a representative PMT?

A: There are many vendors of PMTs, among them Hamamatsu Photonics, Photek (UK), Thorlabs, and Newport Corp. The Hamamatsu R3896 is a typical device (Figure 2): it responds to photons in the 180 nm to 900 nm wavelength range using a multi alkali photocathode, has nine dynodes arranged in a circle within an 8 × 24 mm rectangle, and requires an anode bias of 1250 V.

Fig 2: The Hamamatsu R3896 is a typical, basic PMT without associated electronics or power supply; it can be mounted however the user application requires. (Image: Hamamatsu)

The next part of this article looks at a very different vacuum tube: the traveling wave tube, used as the core element of a high power, mm-wave power amplifier.

References

  1. EE World, “Magnetron, Part 1: Application and operating principles”
  2. EE World, “Magnetron, Part 2: History and future”
  3. Wikipedia, “Photoelectric effect”
  4. Khan Academy, “Photoelectric effect”
  5. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Photoelectric effect”
  6. Scientific American, “Einstein’s Legacy: The Photoelectric Effect”
  7. Florida State University, “Concepts in Digital Imaging Technology: Photomultiplier Tubes”
  8. Hamamatsu Photonics, Photomultiplier Tubes: Basics and Applications,
  9. Hamamatsu Photonics, Data sheet Hamamatsu R3896
  10. EE World, “What are RF waveguides? Part 1: context and principles”
  11. EE World, “What are RF waveguides? Part 2: implementation and components”
  12. Radar Tutorial/EU. “Traveling Wave Tube” (very good description and images)
  13. Elsevier Science Direct, “Traveling Wave Tube”
  14. Tutorials Point, “Travelling Wave Tube” (readable, somewhat simplified)
  15. Microwaves 101, “Traveling Wave Tubes” (has close-in photos of custom made, non-commercial TWTs)
  16. Engineering and Technology History Wiki, Rudolf Kompfner
  17. Microwave Journal, Military Microwaves Supplement, “TWTAs Still Dominate High-Power and mmWave Applications”
  18. dB control/Heico, “What’s Better – TWTAs or SSPAs?
  19. Greek Microwave Group, “TWTs vs SSPAs”
  20. Microwave Journal, “ABI Research Finds Microwave Tube Market Still Strong at Over $1B for 2018”
  21. Semantic Scholar, “Communication satellite power amplifiers: current and future SSPA and TWTA technologies”

 

You may also like:


  • Vacuum tubes we still (have to) use: The traveling wave…
  • traveling wave tube
    Vacuum tubes we still (have to) use: The traveling wave…
  • photomultiplier tube
    Vacuum tubes we still (have to) use: The photomultiplier tube,…
  • rf waveguides
    What are RF waveguides? Part 2: implementation and components
  • rf waveguides
    What are RF waveguides? Part 1: context and principles
  • magnetron
    Magnetron, Part 2: History and future
  • magnetron
    Magnetron, Part 1: Application and operating principles

Filed Under: FAQ, Featured Tagged With: FAQ, hamamatsu

Primary Sidebar

Featured Contributions

Design a circuit for ultra-low power sensor applications

Active baluns bridge the microwave and digital worlds

Managing design complexity and global collaboration with IP-centric design

PCB design best practices for ECAD/MCAD collaboration

Open RAN networks pass the time

More Featured Contributions

EE TECH TOOLBOX

“ee
Tech Toolbox: 5G Technology
This Tech Toolbox covers the basics of 5G technology plus a story about how engineers designed and built a prototype DSL router mostly from old cellphone parts. Download this first 5G/wired/wireless communications Tech Toolbox to learn more!

EE LEARNING CENTER

EE Learning Center
“analog
EXPAND YOUR KNOWLEDGE AND STAY CONNECTED
Get the latest info on technologies, tools and strategies for EE professionals.

EE ENGINEERING TRAINING DAYS

engineering

RSS Current EDABoard.com discussions

  • Diode recovery test Irrm timing.
  • How to make string LEDs?
  • The Analog Gods Hate Me
  • Battery Deep Discharge – IC Workarounds?
  • Safe Current and Power Density Limits in PCB Copper(in A/m² and W/m³) simulation

RSS Current Electro-Tech-Online.com Discussions

  • Raise your hand if your car had one of these:
  • Tektronix 2235 channel 1 trace unstable
  • How to make string LEDs?
  • Wideband matching an electrically short bowtie antenna; 50 ohm, 434 MHz
  • The Analog Gods Hate Me
“bills

Design Fast

Component Selection Made Simple.

Try it Today
design fast globle

Footer

Analog IC Tips

EE WORLD ONLINE NETWORK

  • 5G Technology World
  • EE World Online
  • Engineers Garage
  • Battery Power Tips
  • Connector Tips
  • DesignFast
  • EDA Board Forums
  • Electro Tech Online Forums
  • EV Engineering
  • Microcontroller Tips
  • Power Electronic Tips
  • Sensor Tips
  • Test and Measurement Tips

ANALOG IC TIPS

  • Subscribe to our newsletter
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
  • About us

Copyright © 2025 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy